....  

Research

Student
Achievement

Collection Analysis

Collection Development Plan

Ordering Procedures

Quick Quotes

 News Articles

Community Views and Funding Impact Statements
 

Follett Titlewave Ordering Tips
 
Baltimore County Public Schools Receives 10.529 Million to Upgrade School Library Collections.
See PowerPoint presentation, "Turning Data Into Dollars: The Library Renaissance in Baltimore County Public Schools" for strategies to win support. (Scroll down to section Friday March 16, Session E103)
 

.
 2001-2002 Secondary School Library Collection Maintenance Program

 
 

 

QUICK FACTS

Contacts
Della Curtis, Coordinator, LIS
Arthur Stritch Supervisor, LIS
Curriculum onLINE
Baltimore County Council
Baltimore County Schools

COLLECTION QUALITY
Collection Currency

12.4 % of all high school collections are copyrighted in 1990's

22.3 % of all middle school collections are copyrighted in 1990's

35 % of all elementary school collections are copyrighted in 1990's. The percentage is higher due to the influx of funding from the School Accountability for Excellence (S.A.F.E.) grant, Elementary School Library Enhancement Program which provided an extra $15.00 per pupil towards the purchase of new library materials.


COLLECTION QUALITY
Items per Pupil (IPP)

91% of high schools have 10 or less IPP

80% of middle schools have 10 or less IPP

78% of elementary schools have 10 or less IPP


NEWS ARTICLES
Funding of School Libraries

Library Renaissance in Baltimore: An Open and Shut Case for Library Funding
MultiMedia Schools Journal
Nov/Dec 2000
Article written by Della Curtis, Coordinator of Library Information Services, that summarizes the process and strategies to upgrade library collections.

Outdated School Libraries: What Can You Do to Update
Yours?

Education World,
August 2000
Advice from Della Curtis, Coordinator of Library Information Services and comments from librarians and other experts on the state of the nation's school libraries.

A Recipe for Success:
School Librarians Convince the Baltimore County School District to Spend More Money on Books
School Library Journal
May 2000

10.5 Million Budget
Out with the Old at School Libraries in Baltimore County Maryland
Baltimore Sun 4/15/2000
(archived)

Misinformation Services: Nation's School Libraries Desperate for Funding
ABC News, Feb. 7, 2000

Lamenting Libraries. Washington Post, 1/31/2000 news article

Baltimore County Schools Eye Library Holdings. Sunpapers, 2/6/2000 (archived)

Libraries on Life Support
Education Week, 2/2000

MSDE Task Force Report: School Libraries Need Updating

National Education Association (NEA)
1999-2000 Resolution B-57. School Libraries/Media Programs

Sen. Reed Introduces School Library Media Resources Bill; Action Needed

Era of Neglect Is Evident in Libraries

Library Spending Gaining Some Lost Ground

Small Change: Expenditures for Resources in School Library Media Centers, FY 1995-96

Libraries/Media Centers in Schools: Are There Sufficient Resources?

How Do You Measure Up? Library Budgets Have Bounced Back and Salaries Are Up. But Are School Libraries Benefiting from the Bullish Economy?

Turning Data Into Dollars: The Library Renaissance in Baltimore County Public Schools. Presentation given by Della Curtis, Coordinator of Library information Services at Computers in Libraries (March 16, 2001) and the Pennsylvania Library Association (April 27, 2001). (Scroll down to section Friday March 16, Session E103)

Facts and Figures
from the American Library Association
 

Contacts
Della Curtis, Coordinator, LIS
Arthur Stritch Supervisor, LIS
Curriculum onLINE
Baltimore County Council
Baltimore County Schools

 FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What does the research tell us about school
libraries and
student achievement?

Study Shows Rise in Test Scores
Tied to School Library Resources

Look for full results in
School Library Journal, April 2000 issue!

What knowledge and skills are library media specialists responsible for teaching students and how does it connect with the Maryland School Performance Assessment Program (MSPAP)and the High School Assessment initiative?

In a nutshell, librarians teach students how to use information for creative thinking and problem solving and promote the habit of reading for pleasure. Reading comprehension and critical thinking are skills students need in order to be successful with MSPAP and the High School Performance assessment initiatives. Learning how to access, read, and evaluate information are basic skills; however, applying higher-level thinking skills to convert information into knowledge and wisdom is the primary focus of MSPAP. Libraries are places where students find reading materials and practice MSPAP competencies through reading enrichment and guided research activities. It is urgent that students have available to them current and appealing information in all formats to read ..books, magazines, newspapers, Internet-based, fee-based electronic information services (see BCPS' services), CD-ROM, and media such as video, TV. and radio transcripts. These make up ever-growing information landscape that students must learn to read and use for successful living and learning.

The content and skills which library media specialists teach are outlined in Information Power. These are the Information Literacy Standards for Student Learning. In addition, the Maryland State Department of Education outlines content and skills in the Library Media Learning Outcomes (proposed revision Fall 2000).

The American Library Association has available a great website for Resources for Library Media Specialists to Implement Information Power (Literacy). Also, read an insightful article in Education Week, Libraries Seeking Updated Roll as Learning Center.

Why do students need library books when they have the Internet?


The reality is that students need both; and, the challenge is that students learn how to be effective consumers of all kinds of information, regardless of the format.
Effective consumers of information learn how to ask essential questions such as: "Who is the author of this source of information? By was authority does this person write this information? What is this author's point of view and why? Who paid this author to write this information and why?

With instant access via the Internet to an ever-increasing information base, there is a tendency for students to seek quick answers to complex problems. "There is an all-too-common faith that the electronic sources are accurate, complete, and up-to-date," according to G.Edward Evans, author of Developing Library and Information Center Collections, c2000. Evans further states, "Even if the brave new world of electronic information comes to pass, there will be a need to locally maintain library collections. Paper-based resources continue to be a major source for scholarly activity."

Also, in our brave new world, anyone can be a publisher of information, all it takes is for one to learn how to design webpages and upload the information on to an Internet server. This is not a difficult task for the digital generation or any adult who wishes to do so! The Internet is one of the most democratic institutions since the invention of the printing press, and, as such, it offers anyone a place to communicate whatever they wish.reliable and unreliable, good and bad, biased and non-biased, accurate or inaccurate.

One of the important missions of the school library media specialists is to develop a collection of materials..print, electronic, and nonprint.. which support the learning, reading, and research needs of students. Collection development is their art and skill for which they have been trained to do. Librarians today are using information technologies such as the Internet to develop "virtual libraries" of highly-recommended and authoritative resources which were only available a few years ago in print format, i.e., Gale's Literature Resource Center. The challenge is to know the curriculum and the needs of the students, select reliable resources, and make cost-effective purchasing decisions based on these needs and the most effective information delivery system...the bookshelf or information technologies such as the Internet.

Read this insightful article by Dr. Jamie McKenzie, Editor
The Educational Technology Journal
When the Book? When the Net? Updated article, March 2000

How did library media specialists determine the quality
of the school library media collection?

Library media specialists examined the collection in three ways:
(a) currency ­ copyright date is less than 12 years old or c1988 or newer;
(b) items per pupil
(c) quantity.

 COLLECTION ANALYSIS CRITERIA

  • MSDE COLLECTION SIZE Standards for School Libraries (12,000 items for elementary libraries; 15,000 items for middle school libraries; 18,000 items for high school libraries)
  • MSDE Standard for ITEMS PER PUPIL (IPP) (20 IPP for elementary; 25 IPP for middle; 30 IPP for high school libraries)
  • CURRENCY of the Collection in Copyright Sensitive Content Areas (Determined by research done by the Office of Library Information Services)
 

Currency of information is more critical in some subject areas than in others. For example, copyright date is not as important in literature, languages, or history; however, it is in subject areas such politics and government, economics, social services, education, commerce, communications, transportation, astronomy, allied sciences, earth sciences, paleontology, paleozoology, life sciences, medical sciences, medicine, engineering, physical geography, and cultural studies. These areas were identified as "copyright-sensitive" areas. Once the records were sorted by copyright date, an inventory report by copyright date was generated for each school. This report gave library media specialists data to determine the purchasing priorities.

Items per pupil was determined by dividing the enrollment of each school into the total collection inventory (all subject areas). The MSDE Standard for items per pupil is as follows: (a) 20 for elementary, (b) 25 for middle, and (c) 30 for high school.

What conclusions were made from the collection analysis?

School library collections are at various stages of development. Two rating scales were devised to rank school collections by currency and items per pupil.

CURRENCY RATING SCALE
 Ranking Percent of collection
that is current
Number of items
 Critical Need 0-40%  0-7,200 (H.S).
0-6,000 (M)
0-4,800 (E)
Needs Improvement  41-69%  7,200-12,420 (H.S)
6,001-10,350 (M)
4,801-8,280 (E)
Satisfactory  70-80%   12,421-14,400 (H.S)
10,350- 12,000 (M)
8,281-9,600 (E) 
 
 Excellent  80% +   14,401 + (H.S)
12,001 + (M)
9,601 + (E)

ITEMS PER PUPIL
 Ranking Number of Items Per Pupil
 Critical Need 0-5
Needs Improvement  6-10 
Satisfactory  11-16  
 Excellent  17 +  

 

 

 How did we prove the need for funding?

Step I Clearly identify the problem and the impact on student achievement. Identify the resources (material and human) which can assist with resolving the problem.

Step II Do the "homework" and organize your information for easy access. Gather statistics such as funding history, collection data, price indices; convert the data into graphic representations for readability an impact; research school library standards; read the research regarding the impact school libraries has on student achievement; promote the library instructional program; identify and involve the stake holders in the solution; develop a public information plan; "visualize" the end result; develop strategies to get there. and stand ready to answer all questions with "the facts."

Step III Conduct an extensive collection analysis to prove the need for funding . See above. Utilize the power of library automated catalogs and circulation systems to generate collection statistics to illustrate the need to upgrade library resources. Manipulate the data in various ways to reveal not only the "size" of the collection but also the "quality" of the collection. Quality was determined by examining the copyright sensitive areas such as astronomy, geography and travel, politics, economics, health sciences, technology, world cultures, government, communication, transportation, engineering and allied operations, commerce, paleontology, social services, education, medical sciences, earth sciences, etc. Take from the shelves a few poignant examples of outdated information to have readily available to show the stake holders. Don't forget to do a physical examination of books in the history section...perspectives do change! Sharing the "shelf of shame" proved to be a most effective strategy...the physical evidence allows persons to "dig deeper" into the collection analysis. Note: In the early 90's BCPS libraries did an extensive weeding in preparation for retrospective conversion of library inventories to the automated catalog system; however, not all items were removed because there would be very little on the shelves...the best of the worst was left. Keep in mind that shelves full of outdated books is dangerous because it fosters complacency. As long as the stake holders see books on the library shelves, it is easy to ignore the fact that many of those books may be worthless, misinformation resources. There in lies the essential and powerful strategy to conduct an extensive collection analysis to uncover the truth about the quality of the collection.

Step IV Compare the collection analysis data for each school with library state collection standards. See Maryland Standards. Represent the data in graphic form..a picture is worth a thousand words! Take another view...what would the collection size be if all worthless books were removed? How would the library collection measure up to the state standard for size and IPP? Do the math. Take the "reduced inventory" (items that are still good information resources) and subtract from the standard for collection size and IPP. The answer is the number of items needed to purchase to meet state standards.
The next math function will be the most shocking....multiply the items needed by the average cost of a book. NOTE: The average discounted purchase price of a book for secondary schools is $25.00; however, this excludes reference books which range from $49.60 - $150.00 per title. For a more detailed listing of library materials costs, see 1998 average prices obtained from the Bowker Annual: Library and Trade Book Almanac, 44th ed. c1999 and information from a book jobber. Not done yet with the math...add all figures for each of the schools in the district to find out the total amount needed to upgrade library collections in the school system. That is how we arrived at the $10.529 million which was proved, requested, and funded. This amount will upgrade library collections to 80% of the state standard for collection size. The remaining 20% needed to reach the state standard will be funded beginning this year by the local school.

How is the 10.529 million funding allocated to the schools?

The Baltimore County Council auditors did their homework, also. Using the collection analysis data the Office of Library Information Services provided, the auditors determined the exact amount each school will receive for the 2000-01 school year. The allotments for middle schools range from $130,000 - $238.000; allotments for high schools range from $146,000 - $326,000. The Office of Library Information Services is responsible for dispersing and maintaining a funding accountability system.

What happens after the 2000-01 funding period?

A minimum annual per pupil amount for library materials will established based on current average book cost indices The MSDE 1996-1998 per pupil expenditure for library materials is reported in the annual publication, Facts about Maryland School Libraries. Call 410 767-0451 for this information.

How will quality collections be developed?

Use technology to work smart and think out of the box! List all the tasks that need to be done, apply knowledge of selection and collection development (remember the courses in grad school?), and identify the resources (information and human) that can assist with the process.

The magnitude of rebuilding library collections is daunting. It must be done effectively, efficiently and accountability. These are the operative words that demanded a technological solution and a partnership with a major book jobber.

Effective in order to develop quality collections to support the curriculum and interests and ability level of the students.

Efficient in order for the ordering process to be completed by library media specialists in a seven-month time frame.

Accountable in order to demonstrate that funding is spent responsibly, equitably, and for its intended purpose.

The Office of Library Services developed Project Specifications of which a technological solution was a key requirement. Two book jobbers responded to the Project Specifications. Presentations by both were made to a committee comprising members of the purchasing, accounting, and library departments. Follett Library Resources was selected by the committee because it could meet ALL of our Project Specifications.

What are the Project Specifications and how will Follett Library Resources work with the Office of Library Information Services to address them?

Spec I: May 2000 Baseline Collection Analysis
School library inventories (MARC records) were exported from the automated catalog and given to Follett to use to generate a baseline snapshot of the collection (the collection analysis done by the Office of Library Information Services was conducted in Dec. 1999). It is essential that we have a baseline snapshot of the collections BEFORE the project begin date (August 30, 2000) so that we can evaluate the results of the initiative. Copies of these reports will be given to library media specialists on the August 30, 2000 Professional Study Day Meeting. A master file copy will remain with the Office of Library Information Services.

Spec II: June 2001 Final Collection Analysis
Will be used by the Office of Library Information Services and the Office of Research and Data Analysis to measure the collection growth. and along with other school system data, the impact that library media centers have on student achievement.

Spec III: Online ordering with Password Protection
Since Follett already had an online ordering system in place (Titlewave at www.titlewave.com), it was compelling that we use it for our purposes. This is a definite time-saver for library media specialists..no typing, photocopying of 5 sets of orders, The online ordering information must include reading level, title, author, ISBN number, cost, check box to select, and arranged by Dewey classification.

Spec IV: Specialized Online Selection Catalogs (5)
The Office of Library Information Services will work closely with Follett to develop catalogs of quality books for library media specialists to make selections. Follett will remove from the catalogs current school library inventories for each school before posting them online. As library media specialists order from each of the catalogs and inventories change, Follett will remove the duplicates from the next catalog in the ordering cycle. The catalogs are as follows:

(1) Core Collection Catalog
H.W. Wilson's authoritative core selection references used are Senior High School Catalog, and the Junior and Middle School Catalog. Phase I Ordering
Phase I Cycle: 8/30 - 10/15, 2000

(2) Curriculum Map Catalog
Keywords and descriptors specific to the BCPS Essential Curriculum indicators were cooperatively generated by all curricular offices and library media specialists. This information was given to Follett in order for their collection development department to search their database of all available publications in order to produce a catalog specific to BCPS curriculum.
Phase II Ordering Cycle: 10/15 -1 1/15, 2000)

(3) Consideration File Catalog
School library media specialists will provide Follett with their local school "wish list" of books recommended by the educational community, books needed to support unique instructional programs, initiatives, and special populations, and recommended books in current review journals.
Phase IV Ordering Cycle: 11/30 - 3/1/2001 Note: If you have your wish list ready before 11/30, Follett will accept it immediately. A school can send a wish list only once.

(4) Gale Reference Catalog
Gale Group worked with Follett to put online their catalog of reference materials for your ordering convenience and fund tracking process.
Phase V Ordering Cycle: 11/15 ­ 12/20, 2001

(5) Grolier Online Catalog
Grolier publications, not available through Follett Library Resources, are now made available to BCPS librarians. This online ordering site was developed by Grolier to address our project specification for a "technology solution" to collection development and online ordering. Use your ID and password to access the system. (Note: For those outside of Baltimore County who wish to access the online system, contact
Della Curtis for a demo ID and password.)
Phase V Ordering Cycle: 11/1 - 12/20, 2000.

(6) Award Winning Books Catalog
Phase III Ordering Cycle: 3/1 - 3/15, 2001

(7) Spring Books Catalog
Newly published books as of March 2001.
Phase VI Ordering Cycle: 3/15 - 3/30, 2001

(8) World Book Online Catalog
World Book publications, not available through Follett Library Resources, are now made available via World Book's new online catalog developed specifically for the Baltimore County library upgrade project. We are extremely pleased that World Book answered our request to streamline collection development and fund tracking using online technology. Use your ID and password to access the system. (Note: For those outside of Baltimore County who wish to access the online system, contact Della Curtis for a demo ID and password.)
Phase VI Ordering Cycle: 3/15 - 4/30, 2001

(9) Professional Collection Catalog
Due to many requests from library media specialists to develop the Professional Collections in school libraries, a special catalog is now available on the Titlewave website.
Phase VI Ordering Cycle: 3/15 - 4/30, 2001

Spec V: Online Fund Tracking
Since the stake holders were involved in helping to obtain the 10.529 million, it is important to keep everyone informed to the completion of the project. Therefore, Follett will include in the online ordering system a fund tracking component. This component will be made available to schools and stake holders in order to monitor each school's legislative district, order status, number of items delivered, amount encumbered, actual dollar spent, and a running balance of the school's allotment.

Spec VI: Cataloging and Processing
Follett will use the catalog and processing specifications on file at Follett Library Resources to catalog and process all book orders. Books will arrive at the school "shelf ready" and be immediately available to students and teachers. MARC records to be uploaded in the school's automated catalog will be made available via the Internet and/or on disk.

Spec VII: Shipment of Materials
All orders will be filled by Follett within 30 days of receipt of the school's order. All shipping costs are the responsibility of Follett.

How will librarians order materials not included in the Follett Online Acquisitions system?

  • Select books according to the Selection Policies established by BCPS. Items must have professional reviews in standard reviewing sources, e.g., School Library Journal, Booklist, Library Journal, etc. Items listed in publisher's catalogs are not considered a reviewed resource.
  • Send Purchase Requisitions for materials not available through Follett to the Office of Library Information Services for review and signature by Della Curtis, the account manager. These materials include:

Marshall Cavendish- Follett carries the trade line only, no reference is
available.

Salem Press - limited titles (Call for availability.)

M.E. Sharpe - limited titles (Call for availability)

  • Grolier publications will be available online for ordering by October 1, 2000. The online catalog will include the same features as the Follett online ordering system.

How are library media specialists held accountable for library expenditures and collection statistics?

Library media specialists are required by the Maryland State Department of Education to submit the Annual School Library Media Center Report. providing information such as collection statistics, scope of information services and materials, staffing statistics, budget data and library technology inventories. The data is compiled by the Maryland State Department of Education, Division of Library Development and Services, School Library Media Services Branch and is published in Facts About Maryland's School Library Media Programs. Call 410 767-0451 for information.

How will library media specialists integrate the use of new books with the curriculum and motivate students to read?

Everyone will be involved with the process from the beginning to the end. The arrival of new books will be a time of celebration and excitement. Library media specialists are experts in integrating the use of information resources with the curriculum, providing reading guidance, and motivating students to read. Now the students will have books they want to read and the books will be sufficient to support all instruction! Library media specialists are required to develop reading promotional programs for students. A website, The Reading Page, developed by Della Curtis, Coordinator of the Office of Library Information Services during the 2000 Summer Curriculum Workshop, provides excellent information about reading motivation, research, instructional strategies, and MSDE reading indicators. The
website will be updated as the year unfolds to include information about the successful reading promotional programs in each of the schools.

 
 
VIEWS FROM THE COMMUNITY

Kids are saying..

Staff is saying..

Parents are saying..
"Books are important because they increase your vocabulary an help keep kids out of trouble." Shelby S.

"You can't snuggle down in bed with a computer." Penny P.

"Reading is the only developmental skill that builds abstract thinking and intelligence." Andrew B.

"School libraries need updating..I found this book on the shelf...First Ladies from Martha Washington to Mamie Eisenhower." Phyllis
 Read more!  Read more!  Read more!
 
Website created by Della Curtis, Coordinator
Office of Library Information Services
6901 Charles Street
Towson, Maryland 21204
410 887-4035
410 887-2968 (fax)
Updated August 12, 2000